I'm 39 years old, my mom passed 7 years ago, and I live with my elderly dad in our family home — but now my broke sister wants to force a sale so she can get some cash. What are my options?

Can your sister force the sale of the family home in Canada?

The first thing to understand is whether your sister has the legal right to force the sale of the family home under Canadian law. This will depend on how your family home is owned and what your mother’s will specifies.

If your parents owned the home as joint tenants, it’s likely that your father automatically inherited your mother’s share of the property when she passed away. This means your sister does not have a claim to the property and cannot force a sale. Joint tenancy is common in Canada because it allows for seamless transfer of ownership between spouses when one dies.

However, if your parents owned the home as tenants in common, your mother’s share could have been left to anyone in her will, including your sister. If your mother made your sister a co-owner through the will, your sister may be able to initiate a partition action in court to force the sale of the house.

A partition action is a legal process where one co-owner of a property requests the court to divide the property or force its sale. In Canada, this process is governed by provincial laws. For example, in Ontario, under the Partition Act, your sister can ask the court to sell the property if all co-owners cannot agree on its fate. The same general principles apply across most Canadian provinces.

Unexpected vet bills don’t have to break the bank

Spot Pet Insurance offers coverage for treatment of accidents, illnesses, prescriptions drugs, emergency care and more.

Plus, their preventative care plan covers things like routine check-ups, microchip implantation, and vaccinations, if you want to give your pet the all-star treatment while you protect your bank account.

Get A Quote

What if your sister can legally force a sale?

If your sister has legal grounds to force a sale, it doesn’t mean all is lost. You have several options, depending on your financial situation and family dynamics:

1. Buy Out Your Sister’s Share: One of the simplest solutions is to buy out your sister’s share of the house. You’d need to have the home appraised to determine its current market value. Then, you could offer to purchase your sister’s portion outright, either through a lump-sum payment or a payment plan, depending on what she agrees to.

You might need a mortgage to cover this cost. In Canada, mortgage rates have been fluctuating, but as of late 2024, they're hovering around 6-7%. If you’re eligible, you could explore a home equity line of credit (HELOC) to leverage the equity in your home to finance this buyout.

2. Rent Payment to Your Sister: If buying out your sister is financially unfeasible, you could offer to pay her rent for her share of the home. A reasonable approach would be to pay a proportionate amount of the home’s rental value, based on how much of the property she owns. For example, if your sister owns one-third of the house, you could pay her one-third of the market rent for the property.

3. Mediation and Family Agreement: Mediation is another option to avoid going to court. Canadian courts encourage families to resolve disputes outside of litigation. You could propose a mediated agreement where your sister defers her claim in exchange for future financial compensation. This is especially useful if your sister is not in immediate financial need but wants assurance of future inheritance.

4. Selling the Home: If neither a buyout nor rent is feasible, selling the house might be the best option. This could be a difficult decision emotionally, but it would allow your family to settle the dispute and avoid financial strain. The proceeds would be divided according to ownership shares, and you could explore other living arrangements with your father.

Consider your father's rights

If your father is still living in the home, it’s essential to consider his rights. In many provinces, even if your mother’s will gave part of the house to your sister, your father may have a life estate. This would grant him the right to live in the house for the rest of his life, regardless of ownership changes. In this case, your sister would have to wait until he passes before she can claim her share or force a sale.

Legal advice is key

Ultimately, the best step is to seek legal advice from a Canadian lawyer specializing in estates and real estate law. They can help you interpret your mother’s will, assess your father’s rights, and evaluate whether your sister has legal standing to force a sale. Each province has slightly different rules, so a local lawyer familiar with provincial laws is essential.

You may also want to consult a financial advisor to determine whether buying out your sister or taking on a new mortgage is financially feasible for you.

Bottom line: Navigating the emotional and legal complexities

Family home disputes are often fraught with emotional and financial complexities. However, by understanding your legal options in Canada, you can navigate this difficult situation with greater clarity. Whether it’s through mediation, buying out your sister, or finding a way to keep your father in the home, there are paths forward that can preserve both your family’s well-being and your financial stability.

Remember, you're not alone — many Canadians find themselves in similar situations, and with the right approach, you can find a solution that works for everyone involved.